Somebody Has to Play the Other Notes

or, The Lament of the Bari Sax Player

By Ron Goldenberg

There is a particular disappointment that comes with opening a new piece of music and discovering that the melody belongs to somebody else.

The flutes have a lovely tune. The trumpets get a grand entrance. You get two long notes, several rests, and something that looks suspiciously like the same bar repeated twelve times.

Welcome to the supporting cast.

As a saxophone player who has moved between instruments, I have developed an appreciation for both sides of this arrangement. Playing the melody is fun. You recognize the tune. You know where you fit. If someone asks what you played, you can hum it.

Try humming a baritone saxophone accompaniment at a dinner party.

People may change seats.

But those other notes deserve a little respect.

A melody needs something underneath it. It needs a foundation, a pulse, and harmony that gives it colour. Sometimes your part supplies movement. Sometimes it adds weight. Sometimes one well-placed note helps the whole band arrive together.

It may not look exciting on the page, but it can make a tremendous difference in the room.

The challenge is that an accompaniment does not always make much sense when you practise it alone. You play your notes at home and wonder what the composer was thinking. The dog howls - the cats run for the hills.

Then you hear the notes played with the band.

Suddenly, that repeated pattern fits under a tune. The long note fills out a chord. The entrance after all those rests turns out to be exactly what the music needed.

That is one of the pleasures of ensemble playing. Your sheet music contains your part of the story. Rehearsal lets you hear the rest.

It also gives us something useful to work on. When the melody is in another section, listen for it. How does your part fit underneath? Does it need to be lighter? More connected? Can you hear the tune while you are playing?

And when the melody finally comes your way (if ever), enjoy it. Your fellow musicians are doing the same work for you.

At the West Island New Horizons Band, we bring different instruments, different levels of experience, and different musical jobs to each piece. We cannot all play the tune all the time. Imagine the volume. Imagine the arguments.

There is satisfaction in helping someone else sound good, and in hearing how much better your own part sounds when everyone joins in.

So the next time you open a piece and find a page full of supporting notes, give them a chance.

Somebody has to play them.

And the band is glad it’s you.